Follow us on  Twitter or Contact Us
AMALGAMATION YES
  • Home
  • Research & Studies
    • Research & Studies
    • Saanich - Victoria Citizens' Assembly
    • Duncan - N. Cowichan Amalgamation
    • Politics >
      • Provincial Capital City Comparisons
      • Big City Mayors' Caucus
      • Integrated Service Delivery (ISD)
      • CRD inventory
      • Understanding the CRD - How decisions are made
      • How is the CRD Board Chair selected?
      • Postcards from London: a few lessons we could learn
      • Candidate Quotes, 2013 Prov. Election
      • CRD Weighted Voting
      • Halifax Central Library
    • Municipal Services >
      • 2016 CRD - Unequal Representation
      • CRD - MVRD Comparison
      • 91 Elected Municipal Officials CRD renumeration in 2013
      • Municipal Councilor Member Expenses
      • Municipal Service Matrix
      • Disaster Response & Emergency Management Plans
      • 9-1-1 Service
      • E & N rail summary
    • Maps & Populations
    • Polls
  • About Us
    • Mission & Founders
    • Board of Directors
    • Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
    • Annual General Meeting 2020
    • Annual General Meeting 2019
    • Annual General Meeting 2018
    • Annual General Meeting 2017
    • Annual General Meeting 2016
    • Annual General Meeting 2015
    • Annual General Meeting 2014
    • Contact Us
  • Get Involved
    • Memberships & Donations
    • Volunteer
    • Keep in Touch & Comment
    • Contact your municipal council and media
    • Letters
  • Events & Media
    • Media Articles
    • AY Press Releases
    • BC Provincial election 2020
    • Victoria By-Election 2020
    • Municipal Election 2018
    • View Royal By-Election, 2017
    • Saanich By-Election 2017
    • BC Provincial election 2017
    • Municipal Election 2014
    • AY Events, News
  • Gallery
    • Abundance of Appointments
    • Bizarre Borders
    • Cacophony of Councils
    • Farrago of Fire Depts.
    • Heaps of Halls
    • Meet the Minister & MLAs
    • Multiplicity of Municipalities
    • Plethora of Police Depts.
    • Proliferation of Politicians
    • Travails of Transportation
    • Warren of Works Depts.
  • Blog
Thinking outside the amalgamation box

Times Colonist Letters
June 10, 2015

Re: “Maybe it’s time for an independent James Bay,” June 5.

Though tongue-in-cheek, Shellie Gudgeon’s commentary had me wondering about what else might lie outside the amalgamation box.

The amalgamation debate is very much framed in terms of a provincial/ municipal state of affairs that goes back to structures set about 150 years ago. Perhaps some things have changed.

The study terms of reference now being debated might usefully be expanded to explore possibilities for new arrangements within existing municipalities, say at a neighbourhood level (like a James Bay).

This could include consideration of the ”convivialities” that Robert Theobald identified in his controversial mid-1990s think-piece, Reworking Success. Neighbouring could be harnessed in positive ways, applying the subsidiarity principle.

The expansion of scope could also engage the provincial/municipal interface, and the prospects for more of an intermediary “city-region state” more province-like in responsibilities and resources than the current Capital Regional District. It could be argued, for example, that the current province is the most redundant level of government for most residents of the capital region, if what is now the CRD could be revamped as more of a sub-province and less of an inter-municipality.

Once these aspects of the current provincial/municipal interface are explored, we might find attractive alternatives to an otherwise unappealing amalgamation status quo — not necessarily more governments, but more and better governance, helping to mediate our collective undeniable fact of multiple “territorial autonomies” in relationship through multiple “functional interdependencies.”

We just might find some better fits with today’s 2015 realities.

Ian Wight
Retired University of Manitoba senior scholar in city planning
North Saanich


- See more at: http://www.timescolonist.com/opinion/letters/thinking-outside-the-amalgamation-box-1.1963237#sthash.rplSlySq.dpuf
Donate
Problems with the website? Email us
Copyright,
​ Capital Region Municipal Amalgamation Society
​1860 Greatford Place,
Victoria, BC, V8R 6M8.
Registered under the  BC Local Elections Campaign Financing Act

8SITE MAP 
Updated  April 16, 2022